Fanatics Review 2026: Unbeatable Licences, 54 Percent One-Star Reviews, and a Chase Card That Never Existed
Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
Fanatics has built something close to unassailable: ten to twenty year exclusive trading card licences with the NFL, NBA and MLB, a new FIFA collectibles exclusive won in 2026, and a scale of licensed sports merchandise nobody else can touch. As a business it is winning. As a place to shop it is rated 3.0 out of 5 across 14,156 Trustpilot reviews, where 54 percent of reviewers give one star, and the Better Business Bureau logged 578 complaints in twelve months. In January 2026 its Topps subsidiary admitted a chase card advertised on an $84.99 box had never been inserted in any box at all.
Quick facts
Fayes Homestyle Score | 4.0 / 10 |
What it is | Licensed sports merchandise, apparel and jerseys, plus Fanatics Collectibles which owns Topps, plus a sportsbook and betting arm |
Leadership | Michael Rubin is CEO and founder |
Trustpilot | 3.0 out of 5 from 14,156 reviews. 54 percent one star, 34 percent five star |
BBB | A+ rating, accredited since March 2006, but 1,439 complaints in three years and 578 in the last twelve months |
Live litigation | Panini's antitrust and tortious interference suit is in discovery with trial likely in 2027 |
New litigation | At least four consumer class actions filed January to February 2026 against Topps over NBA Chrome Mega Boxes |
The thing to know | The most repeated complaint is not shipping. It is refunds being issued as gift cards rather than money |
Why is the business so strong and the experience so bad?
Because they are two different things, and Fanatics has optimised hard for the first.
On the business side, 2026 was a good year. Fanatics won an exclusive FIFA collectibles licence reported in May, struck a new trading card deal with the NBA reported in September, launched a Fanatics credit card in January while targeting $50 billion in annual revenue, expanded physical retail, and grew its sportsbook into new states. The chief executive has publicly ruled out moving into ticket sales and live sports broadcasting, which is a rare case of a company this size saying what it will not do.
On the customer side, the numbers point the other way.
Trustpilot | Share |
One star | 54 percent |
Two star | 4 percent |
Three star | 4 percent |
Four star | 4 percent |
Five star | 34 percent |
Overall | 3.0 out of 5 from 14,156 reviews, 1,027 in the last 12 months |
That is not a middling score, it is a split one. A third of customers are happy and more than half are not, with almost nobody in between. The pattern says the order either works smoothly or goes badly wrong, with little middle ground.

Worth understanding the Better Business Bureau position too, because the A+ rating confuses people. Fanatics is BBB accredited and has been since March 2006, and it holds an A+. It also logged 1,439 complaints in three years, 578 of them in the last twelve months. Those two things are not contradictory. The BBB grade largely measures whether a company responds to and resolves complaints through the BBB process, not how many complaints it generates. Fanatics is good at the former and generates a lot of the latter.
What do people actually complain about?
"Refunds issued as gift cards rather than money, alongside unexpected return fees and unclear final-sale terms, is the sharpest recurring grievance" — Themes observed across the Trustpilot profile; per-theme counts are not exposed by the platform
In rough order of how often they come up: customer support that cannot be reached, with automated phone and chat systems and dropped calls; deliveries missed, delayed or stuck in transit; wrong player name, wrong size, or jerseys with poor finishing; unexpected return fees, unclear final-sale terms, and refunds issued as store credit or gift cards instead of a refund to the original payment method; and sale prices or promotional codes, including a military discount, failing at checkout.
That fourth group is the one worth flagging hardest, because it is a policy issue rather than a logistics failure. A delayed parcel is bad luck. Getting a gift card when you expected your money back is a decision somebody made.
To be fair to Fanatics: it replies to 58 percent of negative Trustpilot reviews, usually within a week, and it apologised publicly over the 2026 Super Bowl merchandise shortage rather than staying quiet. The engagement is real, even if the underlying problems recur.
The Topps box that advertised a card nobody could pull
This is new, it is specific, and it is the most damaging thing in this review because the company itself conceded the facts.
Fanatics Collectibles owns The Topps Company. In the 2025-26 season Topps sold NBA Chrome Basketball Mega Boxes at $84.99, marketed with Chase Exclusive Blue X-Fractors as a headline draw.
In mid-January 2026, Topps emailed customers to say that a packaging printing error meant there was zero chance of pulling one. The initial message said only some boxes lacked the card. Topps then admitted that none of them did. The X-Fractor references were removed from the product and the price was cut from $84.99 to $49.99.
At least four proposed consumer class actions followed between January and February 2026, filed in Florida and elsewhere, alleging false advertising and fraud on behalf of US retail purchasers. Plaintiffs point to the $35 price cut as evidence that the chase card carried real market value.
These are allegations and no court has ruled on them. But the underlying facts are not in dispute, because Topps disclosed them itself: a product was sold for months advertising a card that was never in any box.
The Panini case, and where it stands
Panini sued Fanatics in 2023 for monopolisation and tortious interference. It is still live and it is the one to watch.
In June 2026 Fanatics moved to seal two new Panini allegations. A magistrate judge lifted the secrecy restriction and Panini amended its complaint with the court's approval, reported in August 2026. The new allegations are that Fanatics obtained Panini's confidential licensing information, specifically royalty rates and minimum guarantee schedules, and used it to win the exclusive league and union licences. Panini's filing says Fanatics acquired its long-term exclusives through the use of Panini's confidential information. It does not say how Fanatics allegedly got it.
Fanatics calls the allegations baseless and a delay tactic. The case is in discovery, Fanatics is expected to move for summary judgment, and trial is likely in 2027. Nothing has been proven.
Context matters here, and it cuts both ways. Fanatics has been winning its other fights. A collector class action alleging inflated NBA and NFL card prices was dismissed in 2026 and then dismissed with prejudice after the plaintiffs themselves moved to end it. A judge ruled Fanatics can continue hiring Panini employees. Fanatics has counter-sued Panini. And Panini has separately been accused of the same antitrust violations it levelled at Fanatics.
So the honest framing is that Fanatics has a strong courtroom record so far, and one serious unresolved case alleging misuse of a competitor's confidential data, heading toward a jury.
What is it actually good at?
Selection and speed, which is why a third of reviewers still give it five stars. The licence portfolio means that if a team exists and it has merchandise, Fanatics has it, usually in more sizes and variants than anyone else, often faster. Sale pricing is frequently mentioned as a positive even in otherwise critical reviews.

That is a genuine value proposition and it explains the scale. If you want a specific player's jersey in a specific size in a specific week, the alternative is usually not having it.
Who should buy, and who should walk away
Buy from it when you want something nobody else stocks
For a niche jersey, an obscure team's gear or a specific player's name on the back, Fanatics is often the only realistic source, and that is worth putting up with a mediocre checkout experience for. Pay by credit card so you have a chargeback route, and screenshot the price and the return terms before you confirm.
Walk away if you might need to return it
This is the single clearest piece of advice in the article. Refunds issued as gift cards, unexpected return fees and unclear final-sale terms are the most repeated complaint theme, so if there is any chance the sizing is wrong or the gift will not land, buying from a retailer with a straightforward returns desk is worth paying more for.
Walk away from the sealed trading card product
After a $84.99 box was sold for months advertising a chase card that was never inserted in it, and four class actions followed, buying sealed product from this company on the strength of what is printed on the box is a harder argument to make than it was a year ago.
Buy nothing custom or personalised unless you are certain
Wrong player and wrong size are recurring complaints, and personalised items are typically where final-sale terms bite hardest.
If you buy one thing here, make it this
A plain, standard-sizing item you are confident about: a team cap, a basic tee, a standard replica jersey without personalisation, bought on sale and paid for by credit card. The brand's strengths are breadth and price, and both of those come through cleanly on simple items. Everything that goes wrong in the review record attaches to the other end of the transaction: customisation, sizing uncertainty, and anything you might need to send back.
Questions people actually ask
Is Fanatics legit?
Yes, it is a real and very large company holding official licences from the major leagues, and the majority of orders arrive. The question is not legitimacy but service: 54 percent of 14,156 Trustpilot reviewers give it one star, and the BBB logged 578 complaints in twelve months.
Why is Fanatics A+ on the BBB but 3.0 on Trustpilot?
They measure different things. The BBB grade largely reflects whether a company responds to and resolves complaints through the BBB process, and Fanatics does that, having been accredited since 2006. Trustpilot reflects what customers say about their experience, and 1,439 BBB complaints in three years sits alongside the A+ without contradicting it.
Does Fanatics refund to your card or give store credit?
Both happen, and refunds issued as gift cards rather than money are one of the most repeated complaints. Read the specific return terms on your item before ordering, and pay by credit card so a chargeback remains available.
What is the Topps Mega Box lawsuit about?
Topps, which Fanatics Collectibles owns, sold NBA Chrome Mega Boxes at $84.99 advertising Chase Exclusive Blue X-Fractors. In January 2026 Topps emailed customers to say a packaging printing error meant there was zero chance of pulling one, first saying some boxes lacked it and then that none had it. The price was cut to $49.99 and at least four class actions followed. The allegations are unproven.
Is the Panini lawsuit still going?
Yes. It is in discovery with trial likely in 2027. In August 2026 Panini amended its complaint to allege that Fanatics obtained its confidential royalty rates and minimum guarantee schedules and used them to win the exclusive licences. Fanatics calls the allegations baseless. Nothing has been decided.
Fayes Homestyle Scorecard
Selection and availability | 9.0 / 10 |
Pricing and promotions | 6.5 / 10 |
Order fulfilment | 4.0 / 10 |
Returns and refunds | 2.0 / 10 |
Customer service | 2.5 / 10 |
Claim accuracy | 3.0 / 10 |
Overall Fayes Homestyle Score | 4.0 / 10 |
The bottom line
Fanatics has won the sports merchandise business and lost the argument about whether it is pleasant to buy from. The licence portfolio is extraordinary, the 2026 additions of a FIFA collectibles exclusive and a new NBA card deal extended it further, and the selection genuinely is unmatched. It replies to most of its negative reviews, it apologised publicly over the Super Bowl shortage, it has been accredited with the BBB for twenty years, and it has won nearly every court fight it has been in, including a collector class action dismissed with prejudice in 2026.
What sits against that is a 3.0 Trustpilot score where more than half of 14,156 reviewers give one star, 578 BBB complaints in twelve months, and a complaint pattern whose sharpest theme is not slow delivery but refunds arriving as gift cards instead of money. Add a Topps box sold for months advertising a chase card that was never inserted, admitted by the company and now facing at least four class actions, and a Panini case alleging Fanatics used a competitor's confidential royalty data to win its exclusives, heading for a jury in 2027.
Buy the thing you cannot get elsewhere, keep it simple, pay by card, and read the return terms before you click. Do not buy anything here that you might need to send back.
You might also like
Fashion
Chubbies Review 2026: People Still Like the Shorts, the Parent Company Got Delisted
An honest Chubbies review: comfort ranked second of thirteen by independent testers, against sales down 17 percent, a parent delisted from the NYSE in April 2026 and still reporting substantial doubt about going concern.
Fashion
Spiritual Gangster Review: Sweatshirt Quality, Legging Fit, Sizing and Returns
Spiritual Gangster review: soft LA-made sweatshirts, Nirvana leggings, sizing tips, the 21-day return rule, final sale catches and customer opinions.
Fashion
Patagonia Review: Is This Outdoor Clothing Brand Worth It?
Read our Patagonia review covering jackets, outdoor clothing, backpacks, product quality, sustainability, pricing, and whether Patagonia is worth buying.
0 Comments
No comments yet - be the first to share your thoughts.