McGee & Co Review: Studio McGee’s Design Aesthetic at Home, With an After-Sale Experience to Watch

McGee & Co’s best-documented strength is its design and, in good cases, responsive service. One customer wrote that after a problem with a rug, “their customer service team was incredibly responsive and helpful,” and they received full store credit. Another said “They allowed me to return the item even though it was on sale,” and a third reported “We are very satisfied with the product.” McGee & Co is the retail brand of Studio McGee, founded by Syd and Shea McGee, who started the business in a spare bedroom and became one of America’s best-known design names, partly through their Netflix series. The shop sells furniture, lighting, rugs, textiles and décor in the studio’s signature look: warm neutrals, natural textures, vintage-inspired pieces and a relaxed, modern-traditional feel.

The honest caveat is significant. McGee & Co scores 1.6 out of 5 (“Bad”) on Trustpilot from 570 reviews, 61% one-star. Complaints include chairs that took much longer than the quoted 12–16 weeks after a $4,000 payment, a fee charged for redirecting a $2,300 light fixture (later waived), and a stool that “arrived with portions unfinished.” The company replies to 100% of negative reviews, typically within 48 hours.

Quick Highlights

✅ Signature Studio McGee look: warm neutrals, natural textures, modern-traditional style
✅ Founded by Syd and Shea McGee, who started in a spare bedroom
✅ One of America’s best-known design brands, boosted by Netflix exposure
✅ Curated furniture, lighting, rugs, textiles and décor in one place
✅ Customer service praised as “incredibly responsive and helpful” in some cases
✅ Full store credit offered to resolve a rug care issue
✅ A return accepted on a sale item as a goodwill gesture
✅ Replies to 100% of negative reviews, typically within 48 hours
✅ Cohesive collections make it easy to style a whole room
✅ Vintage-inspired and one-of-a-kind décor pieces
✅ Strong design inspiration through Studio McGee content
✅ A redirection fee was waived after a customer complaint
❌ Trustpilot TrustScore of 1.6/5 (“Bad”) from 570 reviews, 61% one-star
❌ Long lead times on furniture (12–16 weeks quoted, sometimes longer)
❌ Large upfront payments for made-to-order pieces
❌ A stool “arrived with portions unfinished” with no replacement or refund offered
❌ Fees charged for delivery changes
❌ Premium prices, with many items in the thousands
❌ No recent history of inviting reviews, so the sample may skew negative

Why Trust This Review

This review draws on McGee & Co’s Trustpilot profile (570 reviews, 1.6 TrustScore), McGee & Co’s published company information (founders Syd and Shea McGee), and independent home décor coverage. GlossGirly has no commercial relationship with McGee & Co that affects this verdict.

Full Review Breakdown

The Studio McGee Aesthetic

For many shoppers, McGee & Co’s appeal starts with the look. Studio McGee popularized a style that feels both fresh and timeless: warm whites and creams, natural wood, rattan and stone, vintage-inspired rugs, soft linens and lighting with a handmade feel. Syd and Shea McGee grew the business from a spare bedroom into a nationally recognized design brand, and McGee & Co lets fans buy pieces that recreate rooms they’ve seen in the studio’s projects and on Netflix. The collections are curated to work together, so a sofa, rug, lamp and side table from McGee & Co usually look cohesive without much effort. For people who love the style but don’t want to hire a designer, that curation is the real value.

Service: Responsive When It Works

McGee & Co’s positive reviews often describe problems that were resolved well. After a rug care issue, one customer received full store credit and called the team “incredibly responsive and helpful.” Another was allowed to return a sale item, which many retailers refuse. A third said their issue was resolved and they’re “very satisfied with the product.” One customer who was charged a redirection fee on a $2,300 light fixture had it waived. The company replies to every negative review, usually within 48 hours, which shows it takes complaints seriously. When something goes wrong, contacting the team directly and clearly seems to get results more often than not.

Lead Times, Payments and Quality Control

The negative reviews point to three recurring problems. First, lead times: one customer paid $4,000 up front for chairs quoted at 12–16 weeks, and they took longer, which is frustrating with that much money tied up. Made-to-order and imported furniture often has long, uncertain timelines. Second, fees and logistics: an address error on a $2,300 light fixture led to a redirection fee before it was waived. Third, quality control: a rattan and wood stool “arrived with portions unfinished,” and the customer says no replacement or refund was offered. At premium prices, buyers expect flawless finishes. Trustpilot notes McGee & Co hasn’t invited reviews recently, so the sample may skew negative, but the patterns are consistent.

How to Shop McGee & Co Smartly

If you love the style, a few habits reduce risk. Check whether an item is in stock or made to order, and ask for realistic lead times before paying large sums. Confirm your delivery address and contact details carefully to avoid redirection fees. Read the return policy, especially for sale and custom items. Inspect every piece on arrival, photograph any flaws immediately, and contact support quickly, since the team does respond. Consider starting with smaller décor pieces like lighting, pillows or accessories before committing to big furniture. Finally, compare similar styles elsewhere. Studio McGee also designs collections for mass retailers, which offer a similar look for less.

Best Products Worth Buying

McGee & Co Rugs

Vintage-inspired and natural-texture rugs that define the Studio McGee look. One customer had a rug care issue resolved with full store credit. Check care instructions for wool and vintage-style pieces.

McGee & Co Lighting

Statement and handmade-feel lighting, some at premium prices (one customer ordered a $2,300 fixture). Confirm the delivery address carefully to avoid redirection fees.

McGee & Co Accent Chairs & Seating

Upholstered chairs in the studio’s signature fabrics. Ask about lead times before paying, since one buyer’s chairs took longer than the quoted 12–16 weeks.

McGee & Co Décor & Accessories

Vases, baskets, pillows and decorative objects. These are a lower-risk way to bring the Studio McGee look home. Rattan and wood pieces should be inspected for finishing.

What Customers Actually Think

“their customer service team was incredibly responsive and helpful.” — Jacqueline Quinlan, Trustpilot reviewer (rug)

“They allowed me to return the item even though it was on sale.” — Teresa Stone, Trustpilot reviewer

“We are very satisfied with the product.” — Vince Pavese, Trustpilot reviewer

“Purchased chairs that were supposed to be delivered 12-16 weeks.” — Jolanta Rothman, Trustpilot reviewer (chairs)

“I ordered a rattan and wood stool from this company and the stool arrived with portions unfinished.” — Julie Parish, Trustpilot reviewer

Is It Worth It?

Possibly, for fans of the Studio McGee look who want curated pieces that work together and are willing to plan around long lead times. Start with décor and lighting, ask detailed questions before buying big furniture, inspect everything on arrival, and contact the responsive support team quickly if problems come up. The 1.6 Trustpilot score is a clear reason to be cautious with large orders.

Competitors Table

FAQs

Who owns McGee & Co?
Syd and Shea McGee, founders of Studio McGee, who started the business in a spare bedroom.

Is McGee & Co good quality?
Many pieces are well designed, but some buyers report unfinished items and delays. It scores 1.6/5 on Trustpilot.

How long does McGee & Co furniture take to arrive?
Made-to-order furniture can take 12–16 weeks or longer. Ask for current estimates.

Does McGee & Co accept returns?
Policies vary by item. Some customers report helpful resolutions, including returns on sale items.

Does McGee & Co respond to complaints?
Yes, it replies to 100% of negative reviews, typically within 48 hours.

Final Verdict

McGee & Co gives Studio McGee fans a direct way to bring that warm, modern-traditional style home, with curated furniture, lighting, rugs and décor that work together. When problems come up, some customers find the service genuinely responsive, with store credit, sale returns and waived fees.

A 1.6 Trustpilot score, long lead times on large upfront payments, unfinished pieces and logistics fees mean you should shop carefully. Start small, ask questions before big purchases, inspect everything and contact support early. For design lovers who go in prepared, McGee & Co can deliver a beautiful home.

Scorecard